If the Democrats lose control of Congress in the November elections because Democrats have offered too little vision for how to address federal spending and long-term structural deficits, then that strikes me as a fair and reasonable outcome. The Democrats have not. Even if the election turns on competing visions of the role of government in addressing the needs of citizens — that is, if voters turn out Democrats because they somehow prefer the current healthcare system to that recently enacted, or they decide they’d rather hope for the best and take no action on global climate change — well, I disagree with those positions, but at least that would be a fair outcome of a fair debate.

If the Democrats retain control of Congress in the November elections because of their policies reversed the catastrophic recession conditions the country faced in 2007-08, then that also is fair and reasonable.

But if the Democrats lose control of Congress because voters blame them for the current lethargy in the economy, that is an unfair and unreasonable outcome. Yet that seems to be exactly where the electorate is right now. What exactly are the objectionable economic policy actions of the Democrats, anyway? That they enacted the biggest tax cut in history? That they put forth stimulus funds that created (or “saved”) an estimated 3 million jobs?

The accurate way to look at it is that a huge economic tsunami was coming at us, and Obama hastily built a levee that mitigated the damage. Was it a perfect levee? No. But we must remember that the tsunami was coming either way. If Republicans had controlled Congress in 2009, and had pursued policies akin to what they are campaigning on now, what would have been the result? No levee at all. Job losses, which had been running more than 700,000 per month at the time, would have continued longer and deeper. The economic contraction would have lasted longer and been more severe. Budget deficits, which are driven by the recession, would have been worse. We would have absorbed the full brunt of the tsunami.

So if the Democrats lose over their handling of the economy in the short run, that’s just wrong.

Advertisements